Nine textbook driving planners outscore a learned planner in simulation, study says
Andreas Look says the best textbook planner scored 41.8 in the HUGSIM driving simulator, up from 32.0 for UniAD’s learned planner with the same perception system.
Numbers in brackets link to the sources listed below.
Andreas Look reported in an arXiv preprint submitted on 18 November that nine of 16 textbook driving planners outscored UniAD’s learned planner in the HUGSIM simulator[1arXivOld-School Planners Drive (Sometimes) Better Than Learned OnesOpen sourceSources [1]]. All used the same system to perceive their surroundings[2arXivOld-School Planners Drive (Sometimes) Better Than Learned OnesOpen sourceSources [2]].
UniAD’s developers say it combines perception, prediction and planning in one network[4arXivPlanning-oriented Autonomous DrivingOpen sourceSources [4]]. Look replaced only the planner, the component that chooses the vehicle’s path and how to move along it[1arXivOld-School Planners Drive (Sometimes) Better Than Learned OnesOpen sourceSources [1]]. He gave the textbook planners no high-definition map[1arXivOld-School Planners Drive (Sometimes) Better Than Learned OnesOpen sourceSources [1]].
Look reported a driving score of 41.8 for the best textbook planner, compared with 32.0 for UniAD’s planner[2arXivOld-School Planners Drive (Sometimes) Better Than Learned OnesOpen sourceSources [2]]. HUGSIM’s developers say they calculate the score by multiplying a vehicle’s average score over a run by the fraction of the route it completes[5arXivHUGSIM: A Real-Time, Photo-Realistic and Closed-Loop Simulator for Autonomous DrivingOpen sourceSources [5]].
Look found the largest gains when the test vehicle encountered stationary or oncoming cars, and no gain when other cars steered toward it[1arXivOld-School Planners Drive (Sometimes) Better Than Learned OnesOpen sourceSources [1]]. He reported that UniAD’s planner hit a car in 182 runs and that the best textbook planner completed the route in 31 of those runs[1arXivOld-School Planners Drive (Sometimes) Better Than Learned OnesOpen sourceSources [1]].
Sources
- 1Old-School Planners Drive (Sometimes) Better Than Learned Ones
PrimaryarXivAccessed
- 2Old-School Planners Drive (Sometimes) Better Than Learned Ones
PrimaryarXivAccessed
- 3HUGSIM: A Real-Time, Photo-Realistic and Closed-Loop Simulator for Autonomous Driving
PrimaryXDimLabAccessed
- 4Planning-oriented Autonomous Driving
PrimaryarXivAccessed
- 5
ITANU’s newsroom system produced this article with AI and checked it against the sources listed above. How we work

